Mr. Agent

Top Mistakes Sellers Make (And How to Avoid Them)

Article Image

I have worked with dozens of homeowners over the years, some seasoned, some beginners, and despite how well-prepared they were at first, many of them were caught off guard by how complicated and emotional the selling process was. As a real estate agent, part of my job is to assist my clients in avoiding expensive errors that can stall a sale, lower their ending price, or turn what otherwise is an easy transaction into one that's stressful.

Overpricing the Property

Pretty much every person I meet makes this error - and it has serious consequences.

I totally understand it. You've invested time, energy, and money into your home. It means something to you. But unfortunately, buyers don't see it the same way. They're looking at comparable sales, market trends, and value for money. If your home is priced above what the market expects, it will sit online with little interest while other, better-priced properties get snapped up.

Soon enough, that high-priced listing goes stale, and you're stuck having to reduce the price anyway - presumably for less than it might have sold for had it been priced correctly initially.

My advice? Trust the numbers. When I appraise a house, I offer you up-to-date comparable sales, buyer feedback on active listings, and an open pricing strategy. Always the goal is to attract the right buyers early, generate firm interest, and position you for a strong result.

Moving Select

Cutting corners on Presentation

First impressions matter - a lot. You'd be amazed how many buyers decide how they feel about a property within the first 60 seconds.

I've walked into homes where the owner thought, "It's just cosmetic, the buyer can overlook it." But buyers rarely do. Whether it's clutter, chipped paint, pet smells, or an overgrown garden - it all leaves an impression. And when buyers see flaws, they start subtracting dollars in their heads.

Before the first photos are even taken or the open houses begin, I always sit down with my clients to fine-tune the presentation. That might mean breaking out the clutter, making a few quick adjustments, bringing in professional cleaners, or even hiring someone to style the property. And yes, the garden is not overlooked - mow the lawn, clean up the front, and add some new plants in there. It's what makes the world of difference.

Selecting the Incorrect Agent (Or Trying to Sell by Yourself)

Real estate is a people's business. Your agent selection is not merely about listing the house - it's about having someone who is market-savvy, who has a large network of buyers, who can negotiate ferociously on your behalf, and who can help reduce your stress from day one to settlement.

I've seen sellers choose the agent who gave them the highest price estimate - even when it didn't match the data. Or go with a discount agent offering low fees but no service. In both cases, they ended up disappointed with the result.

And how about selling privately? Unless you have marketing skills, negotiation skills, and contract handling experience, it is intimidating. You'll save on commission, but you will definitely sacrifice so much more in your end selling price.

If you are interviewing brokers, ask them. Ask them how they would sell your house, what sales they've done within the last month in your area, and how they would sell your house. I'm always truthful with my sellers - and I think the good brokers are too.

Allowing Emotions to Get in the Way

It's only human nature to be attached to your home. Maybe you raised your kids there or had weekend tear-out parties. But when your home is listed for sale, it becomes a product - and that's what consumers see.

One of the toughest parts of my job is helping clients stay centered during negotiation. When deals are lowballing, or when buyers say something that hurts, it's easy to take it personally.

But emotional reactions can lead to rejecting fine offers or delaying decisions that otherwise would lead to a superb outcome. My role as your agent is to walk you through this objectively and strategically to attain the best price without emotion hijacking the process.

Delaying Legal Documents or Disclosures

It's a behind-the-scenes issue that generally catches sellers by surprise - especially first-time sellers.

In Victoria, for example, sellers are legally required to prepare a Section 32 Vendor Statement before contracts can be signed. I've had clients who were keen to accept an offer, only to be delayed because they hadn't engaged their conveyancer early enough. And trust me - delays can make buyers nervous.

My advice: When we come to sell your property, engage a conveyancer or solicitor. Get your documents in order before the first open home. That way, you're ready to act quickly when a buyer is genuine - and you appear ready and professional.

Final Word: Selling with Confidence

Finally, selling a house is not as easy as listing it and waiting for the buyers to roll in. It is a strategy, timing, trust, and cooperation matter. By avoiding the common traps I've outlined earlier - overpricing, poor presentation, subpar agent selection, emotional decision-making, and legal delay - you are set up for a less stressful, more profitable process.

If you're considering selling or simply want to know what your home could sell for in today's marketplace, just give me a call. I'd love to talk with you, provide you with an up-to-date market overview at no obligation, and assist you with making your next step with confidence.


Reviews from MY CLIENTS

Best decision
We’re a young family so this sale meant everything to us and our future. Choosing Sam was the best decision we made. He managed to transform our anxieties of selling a property into a positive process.
Seller - Malvern East Review star 1Review star 2Review star 3Review star 4Review star 5
Great service
Very professional service
Buyer - Bentleigh East Review star 1Review star 2Review star 3Review star 4Review star 5
A consummate professional
He’s a consummate professional who has a great business acumen. Above all he’s got a friendly nature and puts everyone at ease. At every step of the way, he made sure I was kept in the loop whether it was via phone calls, text messages or emails.
Buyer - Ripponlea, VIC Review star 1Review star 2Review star 3Review star 4Review star 5
Brilliant job!
Working with them was a seamless and professional experience. He did a brilliant job!
Seller - Brighton East Review star 1Review star 2Review star 3Review star 4Review star 5
Honest and genuine
Sam was honest, genuine, knowledgeable and quick to respond at any hour of day or night. No question was too small or hard.
Buyer - Mordialloc, VIC Review star 1Review star 2Review star 3Review star 4Review star 5
Great work, thank you!
Approachable, knowledgeable and a people-first agent. Great work, thank you!
Seller - Caulfield North Review star 1Review star 2Review star 3Review star 4Review star 5
Performed above expectations!
Sam and Felicity performed above expectations again! Very professional and were able to negotiate to drive a great result. We couldn't recommend them highly enough!
Seller - Bentleigh, VIC Review star 1Review star 2Review star 3Review star 4Review star 5
Very happy
Very happy with service.
Seller - Moorabbin, VIC Review star 1Review star 2Review star 3Review star 4Review star 5
We are so happy Sam was our agent
Sams attention to detail, manners and high level ethics is what puts him at the top.
Seller - Parkdale, VIC Review star 1Review star 2Review star 3Review star 4Review star 5
Great professional!
Sam is honest and ethical person who works in very transparent way. He worked hard in the background to get the best outcome for us. Overall he had set the expectation high for himself & his team and was able to deliver more than what we anticipated.
Seller - Bentleigh, VIC Review star 1Review star 2Review star 3Review star 4Review star 5
Sold during complete lockdown!!!
Sold our house during complete lockdown !!!

Sam Is a Legend that transforms the impossible task into 100% Possible success.
Seller - Bentleigh East Review star 1Review star 2Review star 3Review star 4Review star 5
Professionalism and integrity
Sam has sold several properties for my family over the years. The reason we keep going to Sam is simple-his total professionalism and integrity. Behind the scenes, he works tirelessly to create opportunities, and keeps you fully informed. I will certainly consult him again for future sales
Seller - McKinnon, VIC Review star 1Review star 2Review star 3Review star 4Review star 5
A true professional
A true professional and absolute gentleman, we would and have recommended Sam to sell properties for anyone.
Seller - Moorabbin, VIC Review star 1Review star 2Review star 3Review star 4Review star 5
High standards
A Professional Experience of High Standards .
Seller - Murrumbeena, VIC Review star 1Review star 2Review star 3Review star 4Review star 5
Superb local area knowledge
Superb local area knowledge - we would highly recommend Sam in the sale of your home. Timely communication and feedback made us feel extremely comfortable throughout the entire process. He assisted us in achieving a sale well over our set reserve.
Seller - Bentleigh East Review star 1Review star 2Review star 3Review star 4Review star 5
Champion in Sales!
Not just an Agent but a True Champion. Always gets the job done with excellence over and over again !!! Thank you Sam looking forward to working with you in 2021 :-)
Seller - Bentleigh East, VIC Review star 1Review star 2Review star 3Review star 4Review star 5
Top Agent!
Cannot fault Sam, he is a professional and gets things done. Works hard to get results which is why we recommend Sam to everyone looking to sell.
Seller - Parkdale, VIC Review star 1Review star 2Review star 3Review star 4Review star 5
Great price!
Sam gave great advice on the market, and got us a great price!
Seller - Bentleigh, VIC Review star 1Review star 2Review star 3Review star 4Review star 5
A master at assisting in buying or selling
Known Sam since beginning his career in this industry achieving deserving position he is in currently. Proud to note what a master he has turned out to be in assisting clients in buying or selling. I am sure he will go on to be a notable figure in the industry nationwide someday.
Seller - Bentleigh, VIC Review star 1Review star 2Review star 3Review star 4Review star 5
Would strongly recommend him!
Sam was extremely professional and personable, he was able to communicate with us fast, and have difficult conversations with my partner and I. Would strongly recommend him!
Seller - Bentleigh East Review star 1Review star 2Review star 3Review star 4Review star 5
Friendly and professional
Sam was friendly and professional with great market knowledge and we couldn’t have asked for a better experience.

His dedication, expertise and professionalism are truly remarkable. He is always willing to go the extra mile to ensure a seamless process.
Seller - Bentleigh East Review star 1Review star 2Review star 3Review star 4Review star 5
Thank you
Sam was able to provide us with good advice & explain Buxton’s campaigning strategy. He also provided tips about minor improvements to the property to achieve a good result, which we implemented. We sold our property post auction & we thank him for his help with the stressful process!
Buyer - Bentleigh East Review star 1Review star 2Review star 3Review star 4Review star 5
Simply outstanding
Sam Maley from Buxton is simply outstanding, His expertise and dedication made selling our house a breeze. With his guidance, we achieved a great sale price in no time. Plus, his friendly demeanor made the process enjoyable.
Seller - Bonbeach, VIC Review star 1Review star 2Review star 3Review star 4Review star 5
Professional, engaging, reassuring
Sam was very professional, engaging, reassuring and was very clear with the communications throughout the process of selling our mother’s house.

We would have no hesitation in recommending Sam and his team to any other potential sellers.
Seller - Highett, VIC Review star 1Review star 2Review star 3Review star 4Review star 5
Very happy customer
Very happy customer and would recommend highly. Thanks again Sam 🙏🏻
Seller - Hampton, VIC Review star 1Review star 2Review star 3Review star 4Review star 5
Consistent communication
His consistent communication was comforting at a stressful time of selling our property. He would find time to fit us in with our busy life schedules. It was our first time selling a house and he guided us throughout and believe he achieved the best result for our family.
Seller - Aspendale, VIC Review star 1Review star 2Review star 3Review star 4Review star 5
Thanks
Very professional
Seller - Bentleigh East Review star 1Review star 2Review star 3Review star 4Review star 5
AMAZING experience working with him
Sam is very professional, he's having a great knowledge and experience of the Market and knows how to get the best out of it.

AMAZING Experience working with him
Seller - Bentleigh East Review star 1Review star 2Review star 3Review star 4Review star 5
I would highly recommend Sam
Sam had a great understanding of the local market in regard to price and potential buyers. Sam is very easy to deal with and a good communicator. I would highly recommend Sam to anyone looking for an agent in the East Bentleigh area.
Seller - Bentleigh East Review star 1Review star 2Review star 3Review star 4Review star 5
Sam is your man!
Sam was easy to talk to and so knowledgeable about the market and strategies to sell our home. With his advice and expertise we were able to get a result that was far beyond our wildest dreams!
Couldn't recommend Sam enough! If you're thinking about selling your property. Sam is your man!
Seller - Highett, VIC Review star 1Review star 2Review star 3Review star 4Review star 5
Nice guy
An absolute pleasure working with Sam on the sale of our property. He is a great communicator, always maintained a professional approach, extremely knowledgeable and instilled confidence that he would be proactive in getting the best outcome for our property. Also a genuinely nice guy!
Seller - Bentleigh, VIC Review star 1Review star 2Review star 3Review star 4Review star 5
Beyond expectations!!!!!
Beyond expectations!!!!! Highly Recommended to all
Seller - Bentleigh East Review star 1Review star 2Review star 3Review star 4Review star 5
Professional, knowledgeable, does what he promises
Working with both Sam and Paul for Buxton was a great experience. We had a number of meetings with Sam during COVID lockdown, about what we should do/what to expect re when to put our house up for sale. Sam, while always enthusiastic, was realistic about market expectations in an uncertain world.
Jeff & Annette Review star 1Review star 2Review star 3Review star 4Review star 5
Very good agent
Very good agent, I would recommend to anyone

Seller - Bentleigh East Review star 1Review star 2Review star 3Review star 4Review star 5
Would 100% recommend
Was recommended Sam and Felicity from a good friend. And once meeting them, knew instantly they were the agents to sell my apartment. Sam worked tirelessly to get me the best price to start my new life in the country. Would 100% recommend working with them!
Seller - Bentleigh, VIC Review star 1Review star 2Review star 3Review star 4Review star 5
The best agent!
The best agent! Did a fantastic job with selling my apartment in Elwood. He is very professional and knowledgeable and I would highly recommend him and his team to anyone!
Seller - Elwood, VIC Review star 1Review star 2Review star 3Review star 4Review star 5

Recently SOLD

Property Image
11/89 Collins Street
Mentone, VIC 3194

bed1bath1cars1
SOLD - $305,000
Property Image
6A Birdwood Street
Bentleigh East, VIC 3165

bed4bath4cars4
SOLD
Property Image
14 Florence Street
Bentleigh East, VIC 3165

bed4bath2cars2
SOLD
Property Image
15A Shrewsbury Street
Bentleigh East, VIC 3165

bed4bath3cars2
SOLD - $1,770,000
Property Image
8A Marlborough Street
Bentleigh East, VIC 3165

bed4bath3cars2
SOLD
Property Image
43 Howard Road
Dingley Village, VIC 3172

bed3bath2cars3
SOLD - $975,000

Office LOCATIONS

Recent ENQUIRIES

15/10/2025 8:39 PM
Kate from Mckinnon enquired about Sam Maley services.

Hello Sam
I am looking for a house in Bentleigh /carnegie/ glen huntly etc to live in with two kids. Budget is less than X.5. But ideally around X.2M
Please let me know if you have any off market?
28/09/2025 9:56 AM
Greg from Mentone enquired about Sam Maley services.

Hi Sam, I was wondering why you are listed on AI overview as the listed owner of my property and that it is for sale. DEFINITELY NOT on both counts. Please remove this!
30/08/2025 7:15 AM
Sarah from Mentone enquired about Sam Maley services.

Good morning Sam,
I have an employee who works from X80 High St, and was impacted by the outage yesterday. For our records, can you please email me with the times it occurred. Thank you
06/07/2021 11:55 AM
Paul from Ripponlea enquired about Sam Maley services.

Hi Sam please contact me to discuss selling my house. thanks P

Articles - TIPS & IDEAS

Get in TOUCH

Close dialog Agent picture

Message Sam Maley